The Gladiator Nightstick Collection is a vinyl-only greatest hits collection from the Athens-based group Of Montreal. It was released exclusively on Devil in the Woods records in 2004, and included the never-before-released track "Ah, My Kitten," later released as "Keep Sending Me Black Fireworks" on the Sunlandic Twins bonus EP. Brackets denote album upon which song made original appearance.

1. Spike The Senses
2. On The Drive Home
3. My Favorite Boxer
4. Let's Do Everything For The First Time Forever
5. Pancakes For One
6. Lysergic Bliss
7. Happy Yellow Bumble Bee
8. Sleeping In The Beetle Bug
9. Old Familiar Way
10. Was Your Face A Head In The Pillow Case?
11. Rose Robert
12. The Problem With April
13. Ah, My Kitten